Category Archives: technology

Hammerbacher heads big data at Mt Sinai

  • accountable care is a system in which hospitals are paid to keep people healthy
  • the new economic incentives drive a need for data regarding the population being treated
  • Joel Dudley (Director of Informatics at Mount Sinai Medical School) is running diabetic patient data through an algorithm to cluster them according to phenotype and genotype.
  • This work aims to to replace the general guidelines doctors often use in deciding how to treat diabetics and replace them with risk models—powered by genomics, lab tests, billing records, and demographics—making up-to-date predictions about the individual patient a doctor is seeing, not unlike how a Web ad is tailored according to who you are and sites you’ve visited recently.

Source: http://www.technologyreview.com/news/518916/a-hospital-takes-its-own-big-data-medicine/

MIT Technology Review Report: A Cure for Health Care Costs (good infographics)

A Hospital Takes Its Own Big-Data Medicine

The person leading the design of the new computer is Jeff Hammerbacher, a 30-year-old known for being Facebook’s first data scientist. Now Hammerbacher is applying the same data-crunching techniques used to target online advertisements, but this time for a powerful engine that will suck in medical information and spit out predictions that could cut the cost of health care.

With $3 trillion spent annually on health care in the U.S., it could easily be the biggest job for “big data” yet. “We’re going out on a limb—we’re saying this can deliver value to the hospital,” says Hammerbacher.

Mount Sinai has 1,406 beds plus a medical school and treats half a million patients per year. Increasingly, it’s run like an information business: it’s assembled a biobank with 26,735 patient DNA and plasma samples, it finished installing a $120 million electronic medical records system this year, and it has been spending heavily to recruit computing experts like Hammerbacher.

It’s all part of a “monstrously large bet that [data] is going to matter,” says Eric Schadt, the computational biologist who runs Mount Sinai’s Icahn Institute for Genomics and Multiscale Biology, where Hammerbacher is based, and who was himself recruited from the gene sequencing company Pacific Biosciences two years ago.

Mount Sinai hopes data will let it succeed in a health-care system that’s shifting dramatically. Perversely, because hospitals bill by the procedure, they tend to earn more the sicker their patients become. But health-care reform in Washington is pushing hospitals toward a new model, called “accountable care,” in which they will instead be paid to keep people healthy.

Mount Sinai is already part of an experiment that the federal agency overseeing Medicare has organized to test these economic ideas. Last year it joined 250 U.S. doctor’s practices, clinics, and other hospitals in agreeing to track patients more closely. If the medical organizations can cut costs with better results, they’ll share in the savings. If costs go up, they can face penalties.

The new economic incentives, says Schadt, help explain the hospital’s sudden hunger for data, and its heavy spending to hire 150 people during the last year just in the institute he runs. “It’s become ‘Hey, use all your resources and data to better assess the population you are treating,’” he says.

One way Mount Sinai is doing that already is with a computer model where factors like disease, past hospital visits, even race, are used to predict which patients stand the highest chance of returning to the hospital. That model, built using hospital claims data, tells caregivers which chronically ill people need to be showered with follow-up calls and extra help. In a pilot study, the program cut readmissions by half; now the risk score is being used throughout the hospital.

Hammerbacher’s new computing facility is designed to supercharge the discovery of such insights. It will run a version of Hadoop, software that spreads data across many computers and is popular in industries, like e-commerce, that generate large amounts of quick-changing information.

Patient data are slim by comparison, and not very dynamic. Records get added to infrequently—not at all if a patient visits another hospital. That’s a limitation, Hammerbacher says. Yet he hopes big-data technology will be used to search for connections between, say, hospital infections and the DNA of microbes present in an ICU, or to track data streaming in from patients who use at-home monitors.

One person he’ll be working with is Joel Dudley, director of biomedical informatics at Mount Sinai’s medical school. Dudley has been running information gathered on diabetes patients (like blood sugar levels, height, weight, and age) through an algorithm that clusters them into a weblike network of nodes. In “hot spots” where diabetic patients appear similar, he’s then trying to find out if they share genetic attributes. That way DNA information might add to predictions about patients, too.

A goal of this work, which is still unpublished, is to replace the general guidelines doctors often use in deciding how to treat diabetics. Instead, new risk models—powered by genomics, lab tests, billing records, and demographics—could make up-to-date predictions about the individual patient a doctor is seeing, not unlike how a Web ad is tailored according to who you are and sites you’ve visited recently.

That is where the big data comes in. In the future, every patient will be represented by what Dudley calls “large dossier of data.” And before they are treated, or even diagnosed, the goal will be to “compare that to every patient that’s ever walked in the door at Mount Sinai,” he says. “[Then] you can say quantitatively what’s the risk for this person based on all the other patients we’ve seen.”

Jointly Health – analytics for remote monitoring

Jointly Health is the first Big Data Analytics and Closed-Loop Decision Support Platform for Remote Patient Monitoring

From their website:

Company Overview

Jointly Health is a venture-backed company headquartered in Orange County, CA. In collaboration with Qualcomm Life, Jointly Health provides a very disruptive, end-to-end Remote Patient Monitoring and Analytics Platform that can detect changes in health states much earlier and with greater specificity. Jointly Health also makes this information actionable by healthcare professionals inside their existing workflow.

First Application

The first application of Jointly Health is to reduce preventable hospital admissions in patients with complex chronic disease. In the U.S. there are 4 million preventable hospitalizations resulting in $88 billion in preventable costs and unquantifiable amounts of human   suffering. Remote patient monitoring has the potential to reduce these hospitalizations but is plagued by missed intervention opportunities, false alarms and inefficiencies. Jointly Health solves these problems.

Uniqueness

Jointly’s proprietary platform utilizes a number of advanced technologies including Predictive Analytics, Complex-Event Processing, Real-Time Analytics, Signal Processing and Machine Learning and has four distinct advantages.

1. Can collect a wide variety of remote health data at high velocity and volume. This includes multiple types of physiological data, human observational, environmental, contextual, and other meta data.

2. Has an adaptable ecosystem that enables our customers to build complex disease models which we can then execute.

3. Can remotely detect changes in health states much earlier and with greater specificity.

4. Provides healthcare professionals with a closed-loop decision support system for intervention optimization.

————-

From: http://www.medgadget.com/2013/11/futuremed-day-4-the-end-of-the-beginning.html

Kreindler elaborated on the value of high speed data for applications including remote patient monitoring and analytics to proactively detect deteriorating health states before they being to detract from quality of life. The energetic talk concluded by touching on how Jointly Health, in collaboration with Qualcomm Life, harnesses big data and analytics to make “information actionable.”

 

Cth Fund on health management apps

  • 40,000 to 60,000 health and wellness apps
  • health app market estimated to be work $700M in 2012, doubling by end of 2013
  • 52% of smartphone owners have used their device to gather health information
  • 19% have at least one health app on their phone
  • safety-net populations have better-than-expected access to mobile devices and are more likely to use their phones to access health information
  • chronic disease (diabetes and asthma) management apps are often extensions of proven interventions that yield clinical benefits and/or financial savings
  • User’s (particularly older users) most popular features: diagnoses, monitoring BP, BSLs
  • User’s least popular features: medication and exercise reminders
  • Providing feedback on progress supports sustained use
  • 30 – 60% of melanomas screened via a teledermatology app were diagnosed as benign!!!!
  • Asthmapolis is an asthma app that is fully integrated with the rescue inhaler to indicate where and when the inhaler is used, correlate that with weather etc.
  • FDA differentiates between lifestyle apps and apps which send data to clinicians – the latter are considered medical devices and will be regulated.

 

PDF: 1713_SilowCarroll_clinical_mgmt_apps_ib

Source: http://www.commonwealthfund.org/Publications/Issue-Briefs/2013/Nov/Clinical-Management-Apps.aspx?omnicid=20

Craig Venter – visioneer

visioneer (n): a scientist who has not only a clear, big and somewhat hubristic view of the future and his role in it, but the technical know how to make it happen along with the skills to bring money and people to their ideas.

digital biological converter (DBC): converts data into life

“The trouble is the field of science, medicine, universities, biotech companies – you name it – have been so splintered, layers, sub-divided, hacked that people can spend their entire career studying one tiny little cog of life,” he says, “If I could change the science system my prescription for changing the whole thing would be organising it around big goals and building teams to do it. That is what we do – I have created team science versus the university system with 200 prima donnas each with their own little space.”

Source: http://www.theguardian.com/science/2013/oct/13/craig-ventner-mars

PDF: Craig Venter_ ‘This isn’t a fantasy look at the future

Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation

 

This extraordinary resource by the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation was handsomely funded by the Gates Foundation and features interactive data visualisations across a range of country-based and global data sets. The data has been carefully curated and is very handy for looking at risk factors and causes.

IHME

http://www.healthmetricsandevaluation.org/gbd/visualizations/gbd-arrow-diagram

Jeremy Heimans :: movement entrepreneur

From: Aim higher than president

Movement entrepreneurs are digitally savvy outsiders who create new sources of power by aggregating and mobilizing the voices of many.

Tips:

  • Use institutional power but don’t become institutionalised – small groups of passionate people are lean and nimble and have autonomy are more powerful than those in power.
  • Build a movement, not a cult of personality – less susceptible to cock ups.
  • A movement is not an internet meme – build for the long term.

AIRO tracks bloods, steps, sleep, stress automatically – I’m getting one

A likely game changer. AIRO uses a special embedded spectrometer to track not just your heart rate, but also your sleep patterns, workout intensity and calories consumed. It’s even able to break down the nutritional intake of your food.

Site: http://www.getairo.com/
Source: http://www.engadget.com/2013/10/28/airo-wristband/

Lunch date with Dickon

From: Paul Nicolarakis [mailto:paul.nicolarakis@outlook.com]
Sent: Thursday, 24 October 2013 8:09 PM
To: ‘Dickon Smart-Gill’
Subject: RE: Singpaore

Beautifully captured Dickon, and thank you for the eBook (it won’t go anywhere).

References for some of my contributions:

–          Online CBT pioneer: Prof. Helen Christensen/Black Dog Institute > blackdoginstitute.org.au // moodgym etc.

–          Research on protein and satiety in locusts, mice and men > Stephen Simpson

–          The Vitality Group (Sth Africa) – 15 min intro video on front page helpful, similarly 1hr webinar http://www.thevitalitygroup.com/

–          A short White Paper on Health Insurance billing analytics

 

Things we didn’t even get to, but expect to at some stage:

–          Antifragile by Nassim Nicholas Taleb (author of Black Swan) >> totally rocked my world, suspect you might enjoy

–          Very strong case for plant based diet by Michael Greger MD

–          4 Hour Body by Timothy Ferris >> where I started my body hacking journey (slow carbs, protein, cruciferous, blow out, but also stuff on sex etc.)

–          Proteus Digital Health – end to end health monitoring, including blood composition via skin patches (warning: interesting but potential ufero)

–          Scanadu – personal medical tricorder

–          Ginger.io – behavioural health analytics platform

–          Omada Health – evidence-driven, online preventive health programs

–          Eatery by Massive Health – recently acquired by Jawbone, but previously doing some interesting things with diet, analytics and amazon’s mechanical turk  (warning: interesting but potential ufero)

–          Kaggle – data modelling competition platform (I’m mates with its founding chairman)

 

Rough vision for what I want to get going over the next 5 years (from diary post):

Over the next five years, I want to develop a health-generating, outcome-remunerated, scalable, for-profit enterprise dedicated to the effective (i.e. live outcome data and analytics, a la rapid learning health system), efficient (i.e. probably not involving doctors) optimization of population health through the application of mobile-mediated behavioural economics, epigenetics, ubiquitous sensors, real time, predictive analytics and the social determinants of health.

 

 

From: Dickon Smart-Gill [mailto:dickon@outlook.com]
Sent: Thursday, 24 October 2013 7:11 PM
To: ‘Paul Nicolarakis’
Subject: RE: Singpaore

 

Notes from our lunch

 

CBT apps are as effective as face to face with professionals. Mood Gym

 

Body by science – Doug McGuff – high intensity, simple exercises.

 

Eatstop eat attached.  A quick and easy read. I bought it, so please don’t forward it on to others just in case my name is encoded into the pdf somehow.

 

Leangains.com – 16-8 protocol. Obviously this guy is genetically gifted, but the fasting technique works for me too.  The key is ‘never any guilt’ if you mess up one day, simply forget it and try the next day.

 

80/20 rule for weight loss 80% being diet, the 20% being exercise.

 

Vitality – south Africa – interesting model to approach insurance companies.

 

Your potential opportunity with the data analysis for medical insurance claims/fraud. Possibility for the same sales approach that they used in the stock trading world.

 

Cauli dabbed with macadamia oil in an 210 degrees fan oven. Crunchy yet still moistish in the centre. Excellent snack food. I suggested adding turmeric (curcumin) for it’s anti inflammatory characteristics. Though not to modify the taste as that is already in order.

 

Standing desks (we both use them and see the benefits).

 

Feel free to add what I missed.

 

Dickon

 

 

 

 

 

From: Paul Nicolarakis [mailto:paul.nicolarakis@outlook.com]
Sent: Wednesday, 23 October, 2013 7:18 PM
To: ‘Dickon Smart-Gill’
Subject: RE: Singpaore

 

Great. How about 1230 for something meaty at:

 

Royal Mail

2 Finlayson Green

Ascott Raffles Place

 

http://www.ladyironchef.com/2012/12/the-royal-mail-prime-ribs-singapore/

 

 

 

 

From: Dickon Smart-Gill [mailto:dickon@outlook.com]
Sent: Wednesday, 23 October 2013 7:02 PM
To: Paul Nicolarakis
Subject: Re: Singpaore

 

Looking good for lunch. Name the time and place. I’m easy.

Sent from my iPhone
On 23 Oct, 2013, at 15:21, “Paul Nicolarakis” <paul.nicolarakis@outlook.com> wrote:

How are you looking for tomorrow? Any chance of lunch or afternoon instead of evening?

 

 

 

From: Paul Nicolarakis [mailto:paul.nicolarakis@outlook.com]
Sent: Friday, 18 October 2013 10:56 AM
To: ‘Dickon Smart-Gill’
Subject: RE: Singpaore

 

done

 

From: Dickon Smart-Gill [mailto:dickon@outlook.com]
Sent: Thursday, 17 October 2013 12:59 PM
To: Paul Nicolarakis
Subject: Re: Singpaore

 

Pencil in the evening of the 24 th.

Sent from my iPhone
On 17 Oct, 2013, at 8:15, “Paul Nicolarakis” <paul.nicolarakis@outlook.com> wrote:

I’m currently leaving on the 25th Dickon, but may stay longer… shall we try for something on the 24th?

 

Cheers, Paul

 

 

 

From: Dickon Smart-Gill [mailto:dickon@outlook.com]
Sent: Thursday, 17 October 2013 12:01 PM
To: ‘Paul Nicolarakis’
Subject: RE: Singpaore

 

Hi Paul,

 

I’m in Bangkok now.

 

However, on the 24th, 25th 26th, I’m in Singapore.

 

Does that overlap with your travel?

 

Dickon

 

From: Paul Nicolarakis [mailto:paul.nicolarakis@outlook.com]
Sent: Thursday, 17 October, 2013 5:31 AM
To: ‘Dickon Smart-Gill’
Subject: Singpaore

 

Checking in again… will be in Singapore next week, let me know if you’re around for a bevvy. Cheers, Paul

 

 

 

From: Dickon Smart-Gill [mailto:dickon@outlook.com]
Sent: Saturday, 14 September 2013 12:47 PM
To: ‘Paul Nicolarakis’
Subject: RE: g’day

 

I’m in Bangkok right now and will still be in Bangkok on Wednesday.

 

Thanks for the invite, if I were in singapore I would definitely have met up with you.

 

Dickon

 

From: Paul Nicolarakis [mailto:blackfriar@gmail.com]
Sent: Saturday, 14 September, 2013 5:05 AM
To: Dickon Smart-Gill
Subject: g’day

 

Hey Dickon,
Am in town through to Wednesday – would be good to catch up if you’re around?
Cheers, Paul